​​Tessa Lee, Sports journalist reporting on global leagues since 2021.​

Jy Simpkin has been invited to meet with AFL football boss Greg Swann after North Melbourne expressed frustration over the three game suspension handed to forward Paul Curtis. The controversy emerged following the AFL Tribunal's decision to uphold Curtis’ ban for a tackle that concussed West Coast youngster Hamish Davis, with the Kangaroos ultimately choosing not to appeal the ruling.

The decision sparked a strong reaction from Simpkin, who publicly criticised the verdict on social media before later deleting the posts following discussions with club and AFL officials. The incident has reignited debate around player conduct, disciplinary processes, and the AFL's concussion related crackdown.

Simpkin Voices Frustration Over Tribunal Decision

​Former North Melbourne captain Jy Simpkin rarely comments publicly on AFL disciplinary matters, making his reaction to the Curtis suspension particularly notable.

Following the tribunal outcome, Simpkin posted criticism on Instagram, describing the match review process in strongly worded terms. His comments quickly attracted attention across the football community.

After what North Melbourne football manager Todd Viney described as a joint conversation involving the AFL and club officials, Simpkin removed the posts. He now has the opportunity to raise his concerns directly with AFL football boss Greg Swann through a formal meeting.

Viney said the midfielder's frustration reflected a desire to support a teammate rather than create controversy.

“He had some frustrations, probably like we all did,” Viney said.

The club has encouraged Simpkin to use official channels if he wishes to discuss the matter further.

North Melbourne Seeking Clarity

While the Kangaroos have accepted the suspension and will not pursue further legal avenues, club officials remain eager to understand the reasoning behind the tribunal's decision.

Viney confirmed he intends to discuss the matter directly with Swann as part of ongoing communication between clubs and league headquarters.

The AFL has introduced increasingly strict interpretations around dangerous tackles and head injuries in recent seasons. Concussion management remains one of the league's highest priorities as administrators attempt to reduce the risk of serious head trauma.

However, several clubs and players have expressed concern about the consistency of rulings and the challenges defenders face when making split second decisions during tackles.

The Curtis case has become another example of the difficult balance between protecting player welfare and maintaining confidence in the disciplinary system.

Clarkson Urges Players To Use Appropriate Channels

North Melbourne coach Alastair Clarkson addressed the issue but stopped short of directly criticising either Simpkin or the AFL.

The four time premiership coach acknowledged the midfielder's frustration but suggested social media was not the best platform for raising concerns.

Clarkson noted that AFL player contracts include guidelines governing public comments about the game, officials and disciplinary processes.

According to Clarkson, players must avoid comments that unfairly target individuals or undermine confidence in the competition.

The veteran coach said Simpkin understood the situation once reminded of the relevant regulations and accepted the need to retract the posts.

The episode highlights the increasing scrutiny placed on player communications in the social media era, where opinions can spread rapidly and generate significant public discussion.

Curtis Focused On Return

Despite disappointment over the suspension, Paul Curtis has remained engaged with the club while serving his ban.

The talented forward will miss matches against Richmond, Essendon and Port Adelaide before becoming available for selection again.

Clarkson praised Curtis for maintaining a positive attitude and continuing to invest in the team's preparation despite being unavailable for match selection.

The coach expressed confidence that the 22 year old would return refreshed and ready to contribute when his suspension concludes.

Curtis has emerged as an important attacking option for North Melbourne and his absence comes at a time when the club is pushing to continue its improvement under Clarkson.

Fisher And Dawson Disciplined After Fremantle Defeat

Clarkson also addressed the omissions of Zac Fisher and Wil Dawson, who were disciplined following North Melbourne's heavy 124 point loss to Fremantle.

The pair were left out after staying out too late following the defeat, although Clarkson emphasised that the incident was not a major breach of standards.

The coach described the players as remorseful and said they had accepted responsibility for their actions.

Rather than focusing on punishment, Clarkson framed the decision as an opportunity for the players to learn from a mistake during a difficult period for the club.

The incident came in the aftermath of one of North Melbourne's most disappointing performances of the season.

Finals Ambitions Still Alive

Despite recent setbacks and off field distractions, North Melbourne remains in contention to improve its ladder position.

The Kangaroos have not played finals since 2016 but could move into the top 10 with a victory over Richmond at the MCG on Sunday.

The match presents an opportunity to build momentum and continue the progress shown throughout parts of the 2026 campaign.

While discussion around the Curtis suspension is likely to continue in AFL circles, North Melbourne's immediate focus remains on securing wins and climbing the ladder during the second half of the season.

The coming weeks may also provide greater clarity on how the AFL intends to address concerns raised by players and clubs regarding tackle suspensions and tribunal consistency.