Written by Megan Taylor, sports reporter covering international sports since 2020
Zach Merrett trade talk has returned one year after Essendon blocked his move to Hawthorn, with the Bombers now facing the prospect of accepting a far smaller deal for their star midfielder.
Merrett reportedly wanted to join Hawthorn last offseason, when the Hawks put three first-round picks on the table, only for Essendon to push for more before talks collapsed late.
The latest trade debate comes during a busy AFL market period, with seven clubs in a high-stakes race for Lachie Neale’s free agency signature.
Bombers Face Lower Return
Fox Footy reporter Jon Ralph said Essendon’s position has changed sharply 12 months on.
“Essendon is going to have to take roughly half the offer it would have secured for Zach Merrett (last year), 12 months on,” Ralph said via Fox Sports.
“He turns 31 two days before the trade period; it was an offer of three first-round picks - Essendon wanted four, and we know what happened. He’s set on an escape again, and he’s only got a single suitor in Hawthorn.
“The initial consensus is the Dons would get a first-rounder, and then potentially a second-rounder.”
That would be a major shift from last year’s valuation.
Essendon held firm when Merrett’s price was at its highest, but the midfielder’s age and narrow market have now changed the trade picture.
Hawthorn Hold Strong Position
Hawthorn appear well placed if Merrett again pushes for a move.
The Hawks were his preferred destination last year, and with no strong rival bidder mentioned, they could have more control in negotiations.
For Hawthorn, Merrett would bring leadership, ball-winning class and polish to a midfield already pushing toward contention.
For Essendon, the concern is more painful.
A rebuilding list needs young talent, and last year’s three first-round picks would have given the Bombers a powerful draft hand.
Did Essendon Misread The Market?
Essendon’s hardline stance may now be tested by reality.
Keeping Merrett for one more season gave the club short-term stability, but it also carried a clear risk if he asked to leave again.
That risk now appears to be playing out.
A first-round pick and a possible second-rounder would still be useful, but it is well below the reported offer Essendon could have secured last year.
Official AFL trade and draft updates are available through the AFL.
